A packaging quote can look very reasonable—until you consider everything that happens after the materials arrive.
Your team may need to add extra padding before sealing each box. The outer cartons may take up more space than necessary. Or perhaps a small number of products are damaged in transit, creating replacement orders and customer complaints.
These costs don’t always appear on the packaging supplier’s invoice, so they are easy to overlook.
If you’re looking for ways to reduce packaging expenses, start by examining how your current packaging performs throughout your operation. Here are five areas worth checking.
1. Product Damage and Returns
Are products arriving damaged or moving inside the box?
Packaging has one essential job: getting the product to its destination in good condition.
When it doesn’t, the cost can go beyond replacing the damaged item. You may also need to pay for return shipping, repack the replacement, arrange a second delivery, and spend time responding to the customer.
Even if products are not arriving broken, there may be warning signs. For example:
- Products have shifted from their original position.
- Accessories are loose inside the box.
- Bottles or containers are touching each other.
- Customers report scratches, dents, or damaged labels.
- Your team routinely adds extra padding “just in case.”
These issues may indicate that the packaging is not supporting the product in the right places.
A custom molded pulp insert can be designed around a product’s shape, with separate spaces for accessories and support in selected areas. For example, a tray for a glass cosmetic bottle can hold the bottle in position while keeping its cap and label away from areas of pressure.
That said, a tight fit is not always a better fit. If a product is difficult to insert or remove, the packaging may put unnecessary pressure on it. Fragile components may also need clearance rather than direct contact.
The best way to check performance is to test the actual product in the complete packaging system, including the insert, outer box, and intended sealing method.
Ask yourself: Are we spending time or money on damage, replacements, or extra protection that better packaging might help reduce?
2. Packaging Size and Shipping Space
Are you shipping more empty space than necessary?
An oversized box may not seem like a major expense. But when thousands of boxes move through a warehouse or travel across the country, the extra space adds up.
Sometimes a business continues using an existing carton even after the product or packaging has changed. To make everything fit, the packing team fills the remaining space with paper, foam, or air pillows.
This can mean buying more filler, storing larger cartons, and fitting fewer finished packages on a pallet or in a container. Depending on the shipping service, package dimensions may also affect the amount charged.
Before ordering another batch of the same cartons, take a closer look at the space inside:
- How much is needed to protect the product?
- How much is there because the box was originally designed for something else?
- Could the insert and outer box be redesigned together?
- Would a smaller box improve pallet or container loading?
For example, a molded pulp insert designed specifically for a product may reduce the need for loose filler. If the existing outer box is also adjustable, there may be an opportunity to reduce its size.
However, the smallest possible package is not necessarily the best one. Fragile products still need adequate clearance and cushioning. Any reduction in size should be checked against the product’s weight, vulnerable areas, and expected transport conditions.
Ask yourself: Could we reduce the size of the complete package without compromising protection?
3. Packing Time and Labor
Does it take too many steps to pack each product?
Take a moment to watch how one product is packed.
Does an employee have to assemble several pieces, wrap the product, add filler, adjust its position, and then check that nothing moves before closing the box?
Each step may take only a few seconds. But as order volume grows, those seconds can become a meaningful part of the packing operation.
A complicated process can also lead to inconsistencies. One employee may use more filler than another, or a product may be placed differently depending on who packs it.
A well-designed insert can make the process more straightforward. For example, a molded pulp tray with dedicated spaces for a device, cable, and adapter gives the packing team a clear place for each component. Depending on the application, it may also reduce the need for separate bags, dividers, or loose protective materials.
When reviewing a new design, consider how it works in practice:
- Can the product be placed into the insert easily?
- Are the accessories quick to locate and pack?
- Is the fit consistent across production samples?
- Can the customer remove the product without difficulty?
- Does the new design introduce any extra assembly steps?
A tray that holds a product securely but takes too much effort to use may simply move the cost from materials to labor.
Ask yourself: Which packing steps are necessary for protection, and which ones exist because the current packaging doesn’t fit the product well?
4. Storage Space and Packaging Inventory
Are your packaging materials taking up more room than they need?
Before a product is packed, its packaging has to be stored somewhere.
If your warehouse holds several sizes of cartons, different types of filler, separate inserts, and packaging for multiple product versions, the materials can take up considerable space. They also need to be counted, reordered, and kept available when production or fulfillment requires them.
Reducing the number of components may simplify inventory management. But it’s also important to look at how each component is stored.
Check the stacking height
Molded pulp trays can often be nested, but some designs stack more efficiently than others.
A deep tray, limited draft angle, or certain rib structures may result in a taller stack. Even a lightweight tray can take up significant space if each piece adds considerable height.
When reviewing a design, ask your supplier for details such as:
- The number of pieces per stack and the stack height
- The number of pieces per carton
- Carton dimensions
- Estimated container loading quantity
Also check whether the trays are easy to separate. A tightly nested stack may save space but slow down packing or cause deformation if the parts are difficult to pull apart.
Consider whether products can share an insert
If you sell several products with similar shapes and sizes, one insert may be able to accommodate more than one version. This could reduce the number of packaging SKUs and molds you need to manage.
However, a shared design is not always the best choice. If the products differ too much, the insert may need to be oversized or require additional filler for smaller items.
For a closer look at the trade-offs, read Can One Molded Pulp Insert Fit Multiple Product Sizes?
Ask yourself: Could we make packaging easier to store and manage without creating problems during packing or transport?
5. Tooling, Order Quantity, and Other Upfront Costs
Are you comparing the full cost of a packaging change?
When you receive a packaging quote, the unit price is usually the first number you look at. It matters—but it is only one part of the calculation.
A custom packaging project may also involve design, prototypes, sample tooling, production molds, and shipping. Depending on the design, you may need additional outer boxes, labels, or protective materials as well.
Consider how those costs relate to the quantity you expect to use. A mold used for a long-running product can be spread across many orders. For a short trial or a product that may change soon, the same investment represents a much higher cost per package.
Here is a simple example:
| Cost per package | Current packaging | Custom packaging |
|---|---|---|
| Packaging materials | $0.40 | $0.48 |
| Additional filler | $0.10 | $0.02 |
| Packing labor | $0.15 | $0.08 |
| Allocated tooling cost | $0.00 | $0.05 |
| Estimated total | $0.65 | $0.63 |
This is an illustrative example, not a quotation. Shipping, storage, and damage-related costs are not included.
In this example, the custom packaging has a higher material price, but the estimated cost per packed product is slightly lower after accounting for filler, labor, and tooling.
The result could be different for your project. If the order quantity is small or the product design is still changing, custom tooling may not be the most economical choice. An existing packaging solution or a simpler temporary option may make more sense until the design and demand are clearer.
For more on this decision, see Molded Pulp Packaging for Startups: When Is Custom Tooling Worth It?
Ask yourself: Have we compared the costs of developing, purchasing, and using each option—not just the price of the insert?
How to Compare Packaging Costs More Accurately
You don’t need a complicated financial model to begin. Start with the information your purchasing, warehouse, and packing teams already have.
For each packaging option, estimate:
- Packaging materials: The insert, outer box, filler, labels, and other components used per product.
- Development costs: Design, samples, and tooling, divided across the number of packages you realistically expect to use.
- Packing labor: The time required to pack one product, including assembly and quality checks.
- Shipping and storage: The space occupied by both the empty packaging and the finished packed product.
- Damage-related costs: Replacements, returns, and other expenses where reliable information is available.
Then compare the options using the same assumptions. Make sure both provide the level of protection your product needs, and avoid counting a cost twice if it is already included in another figure.
If some numbers are not yet available, a packing trial or a comparison of sample carton sizes can give you a useful starting point.
When Is It Worth Reviewing Your Packaging?
A packaging review can be useful when your business is growing, but you don’t need to wait for a major problem. It may be a good time to take another look if:
- Product damage or customer complaints are increasing.
- Your packing team regularly adds extra protection.
- Shipping or warehouse space is becoming more expensive.
- Order volumes have grown and packing is taking longer.
- You are launching a new product or changing an existing one.
- You want to reduce the number of packaging components.
- You are considering a different packaging material.
You don’t have to redesign every package at once. Start with a product that sells in relatively high volumes, takes a long time to pack, or has recurring damage issues. Reviewing one product can help you understand where a change would have the most value.
A Better Packaging Decision Starts With the Whole Picture
The best place to save money depends on the product and the way it is packed, stored, and shipped. For one business, the opportunity may be a smaller outer carton. For another, it may be a more protective insert or a simpler packing process.
Custom molded pulp packaging can be a useful option when a product needs shaped support or when a business wants to reduce separate packaging components. Whether it makes financial sense depends on the design, order volume, tooling investment, and performance required.
Looking for ways to improve your packaging? Share your product dimensions, weight, current packaging method, and estimated order quantity with InNature Pack. We can help you assess whether a custom molded pulp solution may be suitable for your project.