“We already have a plastic insert for our product. Can you make the same one in molded pulp?”
It’s a question we often hear from brands looking to reduce plastic in their packaging. They already have an insert that works, fits inside their box, and presents their product the way they want. Naturally, they would like to keep as much of that design as possible.
In many cases, an existing plastic insert can be used as the starting point for a molded pulp alternative. The product layout, outer box, and basic packaging functions may all be retained. Some details, however, may need to be adjusted for the new material and manufacturing process.
Here’s what to consider when making the switch.
Why Can’t a Plastic Insert Always Be Copied Exactly?
Plastic and molded pulp inserts are made in different ways. A feature that works well in a thermoformed plastic tray may need a different shape or more space when made from molded pulp.
For example, a small clip on a plastic insert may need to be reshaped so it can be formed and released from a pulp mold. The new clip may look different, but it can still be designed to help hold the product in place.
The existing insert is a useful reference: it shows how your product is arranged, where it needs support, and how the packaging fits together. From there, the design can be adapted for molded pulp.
What Can Usually Stay the Same?
Changing the insert material doesn’t necessarily mean changing the whole package. Depending on your product and the space available, several parts of your existing design may be kept.
Product layout
If you’re happy with the way your products are presented, the molded pulp insert can often follow a similar layout.
A skincare set, for example, may continue to show the serum, cream, and accessories in the same order. Each item can have its own cavity, helping keep the presentation tidy when the box is opened.
There may be small adjustments to the spacing or shape of the cavities, but the overall arrangement can remain familiar.
Existing outer box
Many brands would prefer to keep their current box, especially if it has already been printed or is used across a product range.
A molded pulp insert can be designed to fit an existing box if there is enough room for the product, the insert, and the support it needs. We look at the box’s internal dimensions, the height of the product, and how the insert will sit inside.
If space is tight, we can assess whether a local design adjustment or a change in product placement would help.
Basic packaging functions
A molded pulp insert can be designed to perform many of the same jobs as a plastic insert, such as:
- Keeping a product in a designated position
- Separating products and accessories
- Reducing unwanted movement inside the box
- Creating an organized presentation
How well an insert performs depends on its design, the product, and the complete package. Physical samples help confirm that it works as intended.
Which Parts of the Design May Need to Change?
Your plastic insert provides a starting point, but certain details deserve a closer look before it is converted to molded pulp.
1. Sidewalls and cavity shape
Some plastic inserts have deep cavities with relatively straight sides. In molded pulp, the sidewalls may need a draft angle—a slight slope that helps the part release from the mold.
This can affect the width of a cavity, the space between products, or the way an item sits in the tray. The amount of adjustment depends on the depth and shape of the design.
For instance, a bottle may still sit in the same position, but the sides of its cavity may need to slope slightly. A sample can then be used to check that the bottle fits and presents well.
2. Clips and locking features
Both plastic and molded pulp inserts can use local features to help hold a product in place. If your existing plastic tray has clips, we can first assess whether a similar feature is practical in molded pulp.
Where the original shape is difficult to form or release from the mold, the clip may be reshaped. Alternatively, the product’s contours, local supports, or the outer box can help restrict movement.
For example, a beauty device held by clips in a plastic tray may be secured with similar molded pulp features. If those features are unsuitable for the design, a shaped cavity that supports the body of the device may be another option.
The sample should be checked with the actual product to make sure it stays in position and can still be placed into and removed from the insert comfortably.
3. Small details and narrow spaces
Plastic trays sometimes include narrow gaps, sharp corners, or small recesses for accessories. Some of these details may need more space or a simpler shape in molded pulp.
Depending on the design, this could mean rounding a corner, widening a gap, or moving two accessories slightly farther apart. The aim is to create a feature that can be produced consistently while still working for the product.
4. Material thickness and available space
Molded pulp and plastic can have different thickness and structural requirements. Even if the product stays in the same position, the new insert needs enough room around it for the necessary supports.
This matters most when the existing package is already very compact. If the product almost touches the inside of the box, there may be limited room to change the insert.
There is no single amount of space that works for every project. We assess the product, tray, and box together to see what is practical.
5. Surface finish and appearance
A molded pulp insert will give your package a different look and feel from plastic. It has a fiber-based surface and cannot replicate the transparency of a clear plastic tray.
If the insert is visible when the box is opened, its finish may be an important part of the presentation. Wet-pressed molded pulp is often considered when a smoother, more refined surface is needed. Dry-pressed molded pulp may be suitable for projects where structural support and protection are key priorities.
The right choice depends on the design and the appearance you want. Reviewing a physical sample is the best way to see the color, texture, and finish before proceeding.
Will a Molded Pulp Insert Protect the Product?
A molded pulp insert can be designed to support and separate products during handling and transport. The design might use shaped cavities, local supports, or raised sections to help keep each item in position.
For a set containing several glass bottles, for example, separate cavities can help prevent the bottles from touching. For an electronic device, the insert can support the body while providing a separate space for the cable and accessories.
The insert is only one part of the package, though. The outer box, product weight, contact points, and shipping conditions all affect the result.
When reviewing a molded pulp sample, it helps to check it with your actual product and box:
- Does the product sit in the intended position?
- Is it easy to insert and remove?
- Does it move excessively when the box is handled?
- Are there any scratches or pressure marks on the product?
- Does the insert fit properly inside the outer box?
Depending on the project, drop testing or other transport testing may also be appropriate. This helps you assess the complete package under conditions relevant to your product.
What Does It Cost to Switch From Plastic to Molded Pulp?
A custom molded pulp insert usually requires its own tooling, even when it is based on an existing plastic design. Tooling costs depend on factors such as the insert’s size, structure, production process, and required mold configuration.
The price per insert also depends on the design, material, and order quantity. Molded pulp is not automatically more or less expensive than plastic, so the most useful comparison is based on a quotation for your specific project.
It is also helpful to consider whether the new insert can use your current box and packing process. Those details can affect the overall cost of the change.
How to Get Started
The easiest way to start is to share your existing packaging with us.
You can send us the plastic insert together with the product it holds. If you would like to keep your current outer box, you can send that too. Seeing the complete package helps us understand how the product is positioned, supported, and presented.
Our team can then review the design, assess which features may be retained, and suggest adjustments for a molded pulp version. Once the direction is agreed, samples can be developed for you to check the fit and appearance.
If you are not ready to send physical samples, photos and basic dimensions are a good place to start.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need a new mold for a molded pulp insert?
For a custom insert, usually yes. Molded pulp uses its own tooling, so the existing plastic tooling generally cannot be used to produce the new insert.
Can you work from a physical sample instead of a 3D drawing?
Yes. You can send us your existing plastic insert and product for an initial review. If you also want to keep your current outer box, including it helps us assess the available space. A 3D drawing can be helpful, but it is not essential to start the conversation.
Will the molded pulp insert look exactly like the plastic one?
The overall layout can often be similar, but the surface, color, and some structural details may be different. The design is developed around your product and the functions the insert needs to perform.
Can molded pulp hold small accessories as well as the main product?
Yes. Cables, adapters, replacement heads, and other accessories can have their own spaces in the insert. The cavity design will depend on each item’s size and shape, as well as how easily it needs to be removed.
Ready to Explore a Molded Pulp Alternative?
If you’re considering replacing a plastic insert, you don’t need to redesign it on your own.
Send InNature Pack a photo of your current packaging, or get in touch about sending us a physical sample. We’ll review your existing design and help you explore a molded pulp solution for your product.